They challenge Ricky and Madison for a competition. The quads feel guilty, thinking that they are the reason their parents despise Valentine's Day, and try to change their parents' feelings about the holiday. The quads manage to clean up the house, but are caught when Tom finds a small dog in the cabinet when trying to get some tea for his stomach. Nicky and Ricky eavesdrop to the conversation and get it completely wrong. Dawn comes up with a plan to give Ricky confidence to talk to Avery by having her brothers and Mae try to imitate Avery's accent until Ricky gets used to it. However, things take an even worse turn when Moses sees this and gives Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn uncool nicknames—Suspender Girl, Visor Boy, and Briefcase Man—and Ricky is then invited to be on the stairs with the other cool students and receives the nickname R-Man.
With their parents' help, they agree that it doesn't matter whether they're biologically quads or not. However, the Kramdens easily trick the Harper quads into giving up the quadgoals hashtag by acting sad, cute, adorable and vulnerable. In the end, Nicky learns that popularity isn't everything. A talented ballerina in the class, Eiffel, says that she needs the boys to make her look good and tells Dawn not to come back to class without them. Back at the house, the quads are resting miserably alongside Anne, Tom, and Squishy Paws who had also become sick, though Tom couldn't exactly figure out how Squishy Paws became sick. Avery lets Ricky ask her out. Their heavy weight causes them to sled faster than the Kramdens and beat them in their sleep.
The quads stop the tape after Tom and Anne agree that Valentine's Day is ruined forever. Ricky eventually works his way to the top of the stairs, but Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn start coming up with a plan to get revenge. Nicky, Ricky and Dicky are unable to pay their bills because they ordered everything expecting Trey to pay for them, so they're forced to help arrange for Madison's party. They later learn how to make build shelves, earning enough money to buy the pool. Tom wears a motorcycle outfit so tight he can barely move and carries his accordion around with him everywhere, while Anne crimps her hair and makes unintentionally burned waffles every day. When Dawn and Syd begin fighting over red paint Syd wants to use to put in balloons and throw at cars, Dawn's brothers rush over to the tree house as they believe the paint to be blood.
A big dog then comes up to the quads and shakes slobber all over them. Ricky tries to cover it up by saying they're sleep raps instead and is forced into rapping, but fails and the other students laugh at him. When Dawn pressured them to leave, Eiffel told Dawn that she can't let her in without the boys. Dawn grows tired of her brothers' antics and moves into her own room; the quads realize that they need each other more than they think. Dawn gives up the role and goes to save her brothers. When things get tough, she invites her brothers for a sleepover. However, the trip is in danger of cancellation when no one is willing to accept responsibility for a recent lack of bathroom courtesy.
When Nicky, Ricky, and Dicky decide that Dawn is a bad luck charm, Mae gets Science Bob to help out. However, when the quads manage to get back into the kitchen, they discover that the living room is also a mess and must clean up the house before their parents arrive. Unfortunately, the electricity malfunctions causing the mechanical bull to crash into Anne's book club, making Anne furious. Unfortunately, the Harpers are invited by Aunt Jackie to visit her at her farm which has no Internet access to post the quadgoals picture. Finally, a wealthy woman claims the Harpers' dog as her own and the quads have to get the dog back.
. When the skates get accidentally burned after the fight, Tom and Anne agree to put a theme that combines all the ideas from their kids. Dawn blames Mae at first for the secret getting out before realizing that it was her brothers who did it by mistake. Plot has a sleepover with her friend,. While trying to figure out why he gave it a good review, they realize that Nicky is the Gourmet Guy.
She goes to the glee club to make them beg her to join their club. Things don't turn out so well for Dawn after moving out. The quads learn all the struggle the parents went through to keep their ice-dancing secret before they were exposed. The other children later attempt to be different superheroes, but the children still prefer Nicky. The whole situation ended up running out of control but her brothers stepped in to help. Dawn pushes her brothers into a quad pact that none of them will see the concert without the rest of the quads.
Meanwhile, the mayor comes to tell Tom that his son wants a party and only wants Flying Goggle Boy. Moreover, Dawn gets scared sleeping alone in a room without her brothers. In the end, the quads think of a fair way to decide on the dog's name, and the dog ends up being named Squishy Paws, much to Dawn's delight as that was her name idea. She fails the audition and Rose gets the role. Dicky then puts the thermometer into Squishy Paws' mouth as he also doesn't want to get sick. Unfortunately, Rose gets hurt on stage, so the director casts Dawn as the new Dorothy. Dawn and Dicky's puberty is featured in the episode,.
So, Madison agrees to come check it out. However, wishing to avoid arguing and noise in the early hours of Tom and Anne's anniversary, the punishment is lifted for Saturday morning. So, they borrow a bike from Get Sporty to use as bait. The coach comes back on a wheelchair and overhears them. They are mad that he makes them dress ridiculously and doesn't even bother to learn their names. While seeing Joey in an alley, Dawn notices that a goose named Charity has been hurt and can't fly to join its flock, so she and Mae decide to raise money to help Charity.
Dooley provides them with the cameras and equipment needed. Mae tries to stick up for Dawn, but the girls kick her out, too. So, he takes a picture that Dicky painted and claims it as his own. However, since she still shares bedroom with her brothers, the brothers make it very difficult for the girls. Unfortunately, Rose Durkin also signs up for the role, putting pressure on Dawn to prove that she's the real Dorothy. So, he storms off and agrees to take Madison's offer. The next morning, Dawn transforms into a confident mega-star diva, calling herself BeyDawnce.